When people look into care for anxiety or depression, one question comes up often: should I try medication or therapy for anxiety and low mood, or both? The short answer is that it depends on the person. This guide explains how each option works, when the two are combined, and how the choice is made. It is written for patients and families in Hilliard, Columbus and Central Ohio.

Is medication or therapy better for anxiety and depression?

For many people, neither one is better across the board. Both are effective first options.

The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) explains that treatment for depression, and for generalized anxiety disorder, typically involves therapy, medication or both. The choice depends on a person's needs, preferences and medical situation.

Major guidelines agree:

  • Depression. The American Psychological Association's treatment guideline recommends offering adults either therapy or a newer antidepressant to start. Studies comparing the two found similar effects, or not enough evidence to put one ahead.
  • Anxiety. For generalized anxiety that has a marked effect on daily life, the UK's National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) says to offer either therapy or medication, based on the person's preference, because there is no evidence that either one is better.

What therapy involves

Therapy, or talk therapy, helps you learn new ways of thinking and responding. One of the most studied types is cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). In CBT, you learn to:

  • notice automatic thoughts that are inaccurate or unhelpful
  • question them and see how they affect your feelings and actions
  • change habits that keep worry or low mood going

For anxiety, a type of CBT called exposure therapy helps people face feared situations a little at a time, until the fear goes down.

Therapy takes time and practice, usually over a series of sessions. NIMH notes that even when medication eases symptoms, therapy can help with fears, self-defeating thinking and coping with daily life.

At Elevate, individual therapy uses CBT, mindfulness-based strategies and trauma-informed care.

What medication involves

Antidepressants are commonly used for depression, and some also help with anxiety. Other anti-anxiety medications exist too, and NIMH notes that some are prescribed only for short periods because of the risk of tolerance or dependence.

A few things to know:

  • It takes time. Antidepressants usually take 4 to 8 weeks to work. Sleep, appetite and concentration often improve before mood.
  • Side effects are possible. Common ones include upset stomach, headache and sexual side effects. They are often mild and tend to ease with time.
  • The first weeks need extra care. The FDA advises that people taking antidepressants be watched closely early on. Some people under 25 may have more suicidal thoughts at the start or after a dose change. If this happens, call your provider or 988 right away.
  • Follow-ups matter. At Elevate, follow-up visits are about 30 minutes and check how the medication is working.
  • Never stop on your own. Stopping too soon or too suddenly may cause unpleasant or harmful effects. Talk to your provider first.

Our guide to starting an antidepressant covers the first weeks in more detail. Learn more about medication management, or read what to expect at your first medication visit.

When are therapy and medication used together?

Combining the two is common. NIMH notes that medications are often used together with therapy.

Severity often shapes the plan. For milder depression, NIMH says therapy is often tried first, with medication added later if needed. People with moderate or severe depression usually have medication in the first plan.

NICE lists individual CBT plus an antidepressant first among the options for more severe depression. It notes that therapy sessions can give support while medication takes time to work. The APA guideline also suggests that cognitive therapy plus an antidepressant may raise the chance of a full recovery. For anxiety, NICE suggests adding therapy when medication has helped only partly.

Combining is not required. Therapy alone, or medication alone, is a sound choice for many people.

How combined care works at an integrative psychiatric clinic

NIMH suggests asking a possible therapist whether they can prescribe. At Elevate, one provider does both. Fardowsa Sheikh, PMHNP, a psychiatric mental health nurse practitioner, provides medication management and therapy, so both stay coordinated in one plan. Our guide Nurse practitioner, psychiatrist or therapist: who should you see? explains how these roles differ.

Care can also include nutrition guidance, stress reduction and psychoeducation, which means learning how your condition and treatment work. These are added alongside medication and therapy, never instead of them. Read more about our anxiety treatment and depression treatment.

What shapes the choice

There is no formula. You and your provider talk through things like:

  • How strong your symptoms are, and how much they affect daily life.
  • What you have tried before, what helped, and any side effects you had.
  • Your preferences. The APA and NICE guidelines both stress shared decisions.
  • Other health conditions and medicines. Some medications interact with other medicines or supplements, or do not suit certain health conditions. Tell your provider about everything you take.
  • Pregnancy or breastfeeding. NIMH advises telling your provider, so you can weigh risks and benefits together.
  • Age. Children, teens and older adults may need a different approach.
  • Practical needs. Time, travel and language all matter. At Elevate, visits are in person in Hilliard or by telehealth for patients in Ohio, in English, Somali or Arabic.

Everyday steps that support treatment

These habits do not replace treatment, but NIMH notes they can help alongside it:

  • Move. Just 30 minutes of walking a day can boost mood.
  • Keep a regular sleep schedule, with the same bedtime and wake time.
  • Cut back on caffeine. Less caffeine and enough sleep can ease anxiety when paired with treatment.
  • Practice stress reduction. Exercise, mindfulness and meditation can reduce anxiety and add to the effects of therapy.
  • Eat regular meals and stay in touch with people you trust.
  • Avoid alcohol and drugs, including medicines not prescribed for you.

What if the first approach is not helping?

This is common. NIMH says finding the right treatment may take trial and error, and it can take several tries to find a medication that works with the fewest side effects.

Guidelines describe several next steps: adjusting the plan, switching to a different medication or from medication to therapy, or adding one treatment to the other.

If therapy is not helping after a reasonable time, NIMH advises raising it with your therapist. With medication, tell your provider rather than stopping on your own.

When several treatments have not worked, Elevate may offer GeneSight testing. It gives your provider one more piece of information when choosing a medication.

Frequently asked questions

Can I start with therapy only?

Often, yes. NIMH says therapy is often tried first for milder depression, and NICE says the choice for generalized anxiety can rest on your preference. If symptoms are severe, your provider may suggest adding medication. You decide together.

Can I have therapy and medication with the same provider?

Yes. At Elevate, Fardowsa Sheikh, PMHNP, provides both, so your care sits in one plan.

How long until I know it is working?

It varies. Antidepressants usually take 4 to 8 weeks, and therapy also takes time. Your provider will review your progress at follow-up visits.

Is it OK to ask for a different approach?

Yes. NICE's depression guideline says people should be able to change their mind once treatment has started. If you take medication, keep taking it as prescribed until you have talked with your provider, and call right away if you have problems with it.

Can children have therapy, medication or both?

Yes, depending on the child's needs. Elevate sees patients from age 6, and a parent or guardian takes part in care for younger patients. NIMH notes that effective therapy for children often involves parents, and that medication is often combined with therapy. The APA guideline calls for extra care with medication in young people, with decisions made together with parents.

Book a visit

To talk through whether therapy, medication or both fit you, call 380-236-4272 or book online. You do not need a referral. We are at 3966 Brown Park Drive, Suite E, Hilliard, Ohio 43026.

Call 380-236-4272 Book online

If you are in crisis, call or text 988. In an emergency, call 911.

This article is general information, not medical advice. For advice about your own care, talk with your provider.